Intro to Religion Summary Project

Intro to Religion Summary Project

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

Holy Cities of Pilgrimage



             Into the third week of September, our religion class has begun to discuss outlooks on pilgrimage. The definition for pilgrimage is “a universal quest for the self.” (p.197) We have started looking at two theorists, Mircea Eliade and Edith and Victor Turner. The Turners believed Pilgrimage involved “leaving social convention and joining a temporary communitas.” (p.201) Eliade believed there was a sacred and profane, “the ‘sacred’ is REALLY real and exists as a force larger than society.” (p. 200) Eade and Sallnow and Emile Durkheim are theorists we are planning on covering this week. I was very interested in exploring the major places sought out for pilgrimages. Some major cities are, Lourdes, France, Jerusalem, Mecca, Bodhgaya, and Benares. These are all cities frequently visited by millions of Catholic, Muslim, Buddhist, and Hindu peoples.
            Lourdes, France has developed into a major pilgrimage spot for Roman Catholics. It is home of a beautiful grotto where fourteen year old St. Bernadette, received a message from the Virgin Mary herself. She allegedly appeared to her 18 times at the grotto. Pilgrims travel in search of healing from the water of the natural spring that appeared in the grotto.  Connected with this pilgrimage is often the consumption of or bathing in the Lourdes water. Many believe that the waters possess certain healing powers. There has been 67 recognized miraculous healings. Five million people travel to the small town each year in search of their own miracle.
            Jerusalem is considered one of the world’s holiest cities. It is sacred to three world faiths, Judaism, Christianity and Islam. It is a place where Jewish come to visit the temple of Solomon and Muslims believe the prophet Muhammad ascended into heaven. Christians come to walk in Jesus’ footsteps and follow his Crucifixion. There are three holy cites in Jerusalem, the Western Wall, the Church of the Holy Sepulchre and the Al-Aqsa Mosque. This city is a very popular pilgrimage cite because it is rich with history and religion.
            Mecca is considered the center of the Islamic world and the birthplace of the prophet Muhammad. This sacred land is located on the western part of the Arabian Peninsula in Saudi Arabia. A Muslim follows fundamental practices called “The Five Pillars of Islam”. The hajj pilgrimage is the fifth pillar, which requires a male or female to make at least one trip to Mecca in his or her lifetime. When a pilgrim comes to Mecca, they come dressed in a simple white garment that symbolizes purity. They enter a state of holiness when they enter the masque in Mecca and walk around the shrine of Ka’ba seven times in a counterclockwise direction. Next, entering into the shrine, the pilgrim kisses the sacred stone. A pilgrimage to Mecca is forbidden to all people outside the Muslim faith.
            Bodhgaya is among one of the four most sacred pilgrimage places for Buddhists. It is situated on the Phalgu river in Northern India. Gautama Buddha is believed to have found enlightenment under the sacred Bodhi tree at Bodghaya. Pilgrims tie pray flags to the branches and meditate under it. Monks sit at the base of the tree to meditate and chant. The Bodhi Tree is not the only attraction in Bodhgaya. Two others include, Vajrasana and the Mahabodhi temple. The serene atmosphere is ideal for meditation.
            Benares is located in Northern India, between the Varuna and Ashi rivers. It is a sacred city that stands as a Hindu symbol of religion, tradition, and history. Pilgrims come in search of divine blessings at the ghats in Benares. A ghat is a series of paved steps that lead to water with temples built into its side. These structures were built and owned by the royal families of India. In the morning, the waters are filled with people in hope that the water will wash away their sins. The five major ghats in Benares are, Assi, Dasawamedha, Barnasangam, Panchganga, and Manikarnika. It is the oldest place of learning and is filled with centuries of tradition.










Monday, September 13, 2010

Keeping An Open Mind


This past week, we have explored the ideas of four theorists. These theorists included James Frazer, Emile Durkheim, Sigmund Freud, and Karl Marx. Each theorist had a different outlook on religion. Here is a more in depth look at each theorist and their beliefs.
James Frazer (1854-1941) was a religious theorist who believed that religion was the power that comes from inside the internal person. His field of study included comparative anthropology with sources of mythology and Greek writings. He believed in sympathetic magic where nature works on sympathies or influences. He said, “when nature fails, the primitive peoples made every effort they could to understand the world and change it.” (Pg 34) He suggested that science follows the failure of religion. I was open to the theories Frazer suggested about the contrasts and similarities of magic and religion. It was interesting how he distinguished between the two. When most people’s outlooks are concrete and unwilling to explore possibilities he tried to understand an alternate way.
Emile Durkheim (1858-1917) was sociologist who believed that God, an ultimate reality, is essentially the group or the clan. There will always be a unified group with a unified system of beliefs and practices. He was interested in sources of community ideas and the realm of the mind. He said, “ Religion is a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, things apart and forbidden.” (Pg 99) The totemic principle is the hidden force worshipped by the clan. I think there is always the possibility of change.
Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) was a psychologist who was mostly involved with the field of psychoanalysis. Freud ultimately did not believe in religion. His personal stance is a complete rejection of religious belief. He said, “ They are erroneous, they are superstitions.” (Pg 65) Freud believes that religion is a universe of obsession neurosis; that neurotic people believe in religion and normal people follow science. He thinks that God is an illusion, or an image projected from the self to satisfy a deep need or overcome our guilt. I think someone who is agnostic or atheist is a very pessimistic person. Freud can definitely be described as a weird thinker but I like that he looks outside the box and he finds new and strange outlooks on things.
Karl Marx (1818-1883) was an economic philosopher. He believed there was a higher class and a lower class; the proletariat and the bourgeoisie respectively. He thought the psychical was always better than the ideal. We have creativity and beauty, we can grow and change, but Marx says we have rejected all of that and instead, have projected it in a God figure. He says, “ Religion is pure illusion.” (Pg 138) and, “ the sigh of the oppressed creature.” (Pg 141) He believes the oppressed creature clings to religion as their hope. I think Marx was very close-minded in the fact that he tried to put everything into the economic standpoint of life. However, compared to Freud who was calling people crazy, Marx explained why we are the way we are.
As a Catholic, many of the theorists we have gone over completely go against my views of religion as a whole. I have been brought up to believe God and his only son are my saviors; they make up everything about my rituals and beliefs. To hear theories about God not existing or that a belief in a God is “crazy” is a tough challenge to comprehend, however, I need to keep an open mind about other world religions and beliefs.